Mulan controversy reddit. 627K subscribers in the HongKong community.
Mulan controversy reddit Mulan, both at the time of its release and today, is a powerful story and shows a strong woman who doesn’t necessarily like being dolled up all the time and doesn’t have the patience to sit down a memorize an admonition for some scummy matchmaker and I don’t think she should be criticized for that. A Subreddit for all things Hong Kong. Indeed, many hoped Mulan would be the crown jewel of Disney’s recent remake project. Rewatch the original Mulan. However, they saw enough to see potential in Premier Access. At first the new Mulan film was getting a lot of heat because Disney, in an attempt to appeal more to the Chinese box office, was making a live action movie based on the original Hua Mulan stories instead of the 1998 animated film. More to come on December 10th Investors' Day" "On the Twitter-like Weibo social media platform, where Liu has nearly 66 million followers, the actress retweeted an image from the Communist Party mouthpiece, the People’s Daily, that reads “I support the Hong Kong police; you can beat me up now” in Chinese and “What a shame for Hong Kong” below in English. Clarification on the Mulan's lead actress controversy As someone who understand Chinese, Liu Yifei was only re-sharing an image that includes a quote from Chinese reporter Fu Guohao who was subsequently assaulted by Hong Kong protesters. But that expected controversy barely scratches the surface compared to the backlash the film has received. I personally don't care much for her design but she seems to be well liked so it's w/e. Changes included it not being a musical, no Eddie Murphy Dragon, no Li Shang, etc. The main problem with mulan (2020) is that it is hollywood gibberish that has nothing to do with the animated film or the legend of Mulan. Second: Action. There was more upset around her design, because they initially teased her wearing her disguise, only to remove it to reveal a more generic boob-armor female design. And Mulan didn’t nudge Michael at all. Instead of Mulan being an ordinary girl who had to overcome hardship to do the impossible, she was a super badass who could do anything, but had to hide her awesomeness because Chinese tradition didn't like women in the military. Such a waste of the cast too. From the Renaissance era, The Lion King, Aladdin, Beauty and the Beast get all the credit, a lot of it is due to the super popular music in these movies. Bob Chapek: "Disney was pleased with the results of "Mulan" as a Premier Access title, but the film faced controversy. Mulan too has great music but I feel outside of the music, Mulan might just be the best from that collection of 10 Li Shang struggles with being attracted to "Ping" and is relieved when he discovers she's actually Mulan - whereas from what I've seen from the press junket, Chen Honghui is just a close platonic friend until he learns Mulan is a woman. Sep 4, 2020 · But Disney's Mulan is facing calls for a boycott in some Asian countries. Sep 8, 2020 · Mulan star Liu Yifei’s comments supporting Hong Kong police sparked criticism of the film, which quickly led to a call for boycotts among Hong Kong pro-democracy protestors, as well as Thai and Sep 11, 2020 · In the lead up to its release, Disney’s live-action Mulan has generated a surprising amount of political controversy. Before even the animated Mulan film, there were already many versions of adaptation of Ballad of Mulan, in the form of films, TV shows, stage plays, etc. In live action, Mulan is just bland, dry storytelling, perfunctory and joyless. She very likely belonged to a "barbarian" tribe (by Chinese standards). In short women empowerment. From Travel, food, events, to local news… 2. One version I can remember had magical elements to it: When Mulan took her father's place and joined the army, the Jade Emperor and the Queen of Heavens found her bravery amusing and made a Mulan shows her wits just at the right time to save them all. Like many viewers, I’d wanted great things from this film. From the president of the Disney Theatrical Group, comes this anecdote: We screened it in New York for Michael Eisner. Apr 15, 2023 · Upon Mulan's release, politicians from the U. This film falls far short of that — and that’s not even considering its controversially high $30 streaming ticket Fun fact: Then CEO Michael Eisner did not get Mulan at all. The original Mulan did a fantastic job of showcasing Mulan as a brave, smart, tenacious and funny individual. S. Have a fun conversation about anything that is on your mind. It feels like a hollywood director said “i know nothing about mulan, or chinese history, or chinese culture, but I can make this better”. Mulan (1998) wins because her. unique personality demonstrates unexpected value. Disney made awesome movies back in the day, then they went under a period where they made pretty poor movies, and now the people who grew up watching the original Disney movies are grown up and have started working for Disney themselves and are making quality movies like before. Mulan was a real person and was in this war situation, the action is supposed to be more grounded, just like the old Disney movie. She succeeds where conventional strength has already failed. however, Disney decide to adopt the Wuxian style of action,, which is basically Chinese version of superhero action. Liu Yifei, the live-action film's star, first angered fans last year with comments reportedly supporting Hong Kong's Mulan I think people have gotten over, I'd say she was the least controversial of the three. Even the original Mulan film grappled with these sorts of issues -- see this article for a discussion of Disney's choice to make Mongolians the villains, a move distancing the film from the source material. I love the fact that Disney has gone back to that model. Notable bad scenes include mulan rescuing the emperor. However, I do want to rant a bit about the main theme of this movie and the original Mulan. The goal of /r/Movies is to provide an inclusive place for discussions and news… The friendlier part of Reddit. Also, in that scene, she isn’t Thing is the original Mulan wasn't even Han Chinese. Ask a question or start a conversation about (almost) anything you desire. Very thrilling. You have to remember that initial plans for this movie date all the way back to 2010, and production started around 2017. It's a similar runtime but there is so much more character development. Shooting in a region of extreme controversy combined with the employment of a mediocre husband and wife writing team and two writers who have nothing even half decent on their resumes. 31M subscribers in the movies community. Mushu and Cricket give us insight into what Mulan is thinking and how she's feeling. policymakers demanding that then-CEO Bob Chapek answer a set of questions regarding the filmling of Mulan and the involvement of the Communist Party. The Chinese government shut out the National Basketball Association last year after the general manager of the Houston Rockets shared an image on Twitter that was supportive of pro-democracy The entire point of making Mulan was to pander to the Chinese government to show Disney could be "pro-China". The “Mulan” controversy underscores the dilemma companies face when trying to balance their core principles with access to the Chinese market. . Essentially, you're championing one cause while undermining the other. The theme and message of the story is that women are capable of much more than society expects of them. At the end, he literally screamed, “Who’s the guy on the bench?!” The problem is, by making Mulan into a trans icon in reference to those aspects, both the song and overall message of female empowerment + Mulan's original legend from which it's inspired are being misrepresented and invite misinterpretation for the sake of LGBT representation. Most likely, Mulan herself was a nomadic "hun", rather than a Han Chinese. Mulan had very small controversy surrounding her inclusion because she isn't considered a 'god' in the way many think. 2K votes, 534 comments. Maybe you'll make some friends in the process. Jesus christ. Without any characters like that, the movie doesn't work. People are also opposed to the "Han-washing" of Mulan. First, in 2019, star Liu Yifei spoke out in support of Hong Kong police Sep 14, 2020 · The live-action remake of Mulan, Disney's animated classic based in Chinese history and mythology, was always going to be vulnerable to criticism due to many of the factors surrounding the film's production. Just to expand on this a bit further, even those with no interest in politics are disappointed with the decisions made in the film. It does not fit the tone. The script is tight. Fans of the animated film were upset to see this remake drop the comic relief dragon/cricket, feature none of the original songs (or any songs at all), and much of the promotional material appears to tone-down the concept of her pretending to be a man to be accepted. She was absolutely added only to try and capitalize off of the movie though, that's fairly obvious. I mean, in the original poetry, the leader that called upon her dad to war, has the same title that Ghengis used, 可汗. 627K subscribers in the HongKong community. She did have shrines and ancestor worship is big so it's w/e. 3K votes, 133 comments. (This will only be about Disney's animated movie, as I'm unfamiliar with the rest) Due to Mulan being biologically a girl but dressing up as a boy and acting like a boy many people consider her to be a trans allegory or trans representation, but that misses the entire point of the character. That's not the only reason for the boycott. and United Kingdom heavily criticized Disney, with U. And that makes Mulan overpowered. Mulan (2020) wins because she's a kung fu chosen one and she fights best. mjtfalh akgdp sji krdcte aeuuzrnt zqe vtgftas fcwgf fenkui olvdxc